Choosing the right suitcase: criteria to consider when deciding between soft and hard cases

Are you getting ready to travel and wondering which suitcase to choose between a soft and a hard suitcase? It's essential to take several criteria into account to make the right choice. In this article, we'll show you what you need to consider to choose the suitcase that best suits your needs.

By Emeline, flight attendant undergoing retraining, aged 44.

Materials and robustness

The choice between a suitcase flexible and a suitcase rigid depends largely on their composition and strength. Rigid cases are generally made of polycarbonate or ABS, offering greater protection against impact. On the other hand, soft cases, often made of nylon or polyester, are better able to absorb minor knocks and impacts.

Weight and handling

Rigid suitcases are often heavier due to their solid construction materials. Conversely, soft cases tend to be lighter, which can be an advantage if you have weight restrictions on your luggage. What's more, hard cases often feature 360-degree swivel wheels, making them easier to handle in congested airports.

Capacity and scalability

Soft-sided suitcases often offer the possibility of expansion thanks to additional zippers, allowing you to gain a few extra centimetres of storage space when needed. Rigid suitcases don't offer this flexibility, but their structure allows internal space to be maximized in a more organized way.

Safety and locks

In terms of security, hard cases provide better protection against theft and damage, thanks to integrated locks and sturdy shells. Soft cases can be broken into more easily, although they are often equipped with multiple lockable or zippered compartments offering some protection against intruders.

Cost and aesthetics

Hard cases are generally more expensive than soft cases, due to their high-quality materials and greater durability. Aesthetically, hard cases are available in a variety of bright colors and modern designs, while soft cases offer more variety in terms of exterior pockets and styles.

Travel environment

If you're a frequent air traveller and often have to go through rough handling, a rigid suitcase will probably be more suitable. For car or train journeys, where the suitcase can be handled with greater care, a soft suitcase may suffice, offering greater flexibility.

List of main criteria

Here's a concise list to help you decide between a soft and a hard suitcase:

Ultimately, the choice between a soft and a hard suitcase depends on your personal preferences and specific travel needs.